Birdman330
Full Access Member
If you've never used the 4WD you probably just have a funky switch. I'd find a very straight road and try cycling it through 2H and 4H and back to work the switch back and forth a few times and possibly free it up. The reason I mention "straight" road is that problems can occur if all four wheels have a good grip on the road and you turn a little in either direction. The front and rear wheels will want to rotate at different speeds while in a turn and can't in 4WD. On a slick road they'll just slide but on a dry surface it will put more stress on the suspension and differentials than you want. I cycle my Jeep in and out of 4WD at least once a month - even in the summer - but only when I know I can go "zero she flies" until I'm back in 2WD.
Avoid 4L until you find your manual and know how to do it and what to expect. It's not a big deal, but you want to be barely moving when you engage 4L and not go very fast in 4L in any case, not that you really can.
Like nullptr mentioned, the switch only turns the light on and off. As long as you know where the lever is positioned you don't need to worry about. A quick search here will tell you how to replace it. It is an easy job and a fairly cheap part and would be worth it when you get around to it, if only as a reminder to disengage it when you hit dry road, for instance during a snowstorm where sections of road have been well plowed and others have not.
Shift on the fly has always bothered me, For some reason I just get horrible visions of driving even at slow speeds, trying to engage the 4WD and the transfer case ending up on the road when it happens, though we had a Liberty that a couple had bought which had Command-Trac where the sensor was bad on it. Salesman brought it through wanting to know what the problem was the Part Time was lit up despite it not having that feature. I told him it was just the sensor so nothing to worry about. If they could live with the part time dash light despite it not having part time they would be fine. Which he said they were.