Search results

  1. V

    HELP NEEDED BAD ENGINE 2005 LiBERTY

    You're welcome! Glad that my experience has been helpful! (Mine was/has been a saga..) IMO $3500 for say, a Jasper reman with their warranty period + improvements on OE design, is wayyy better math than a $2800 engine with who-knows-how-cared for and driven 78k miles on it with a 90 day...
  2. V

    HELP NEEDED BAD ENGINE 2005 LiBERTY

    Hey tomknight, I had a reman installed about a month ago. The Mopar labor guide puts it at a 17.7h job. There's an additional 1-2h for a manual trans tho, so if yours is automatic trans it'd be around 15-16h. From what I understand labor rates vary depending on the region of the country. So...
  3. V

    "Dead" cylinder with compression??

    Soooo this is weird. Looking at clutch kits at RockAuto with my KJ specs. The Platinum Driveline one says:
  4. V

    "Dead" cylinder with compression??

    Update. Mech said it sounds like the TO bearing. Again. The Mopar kit will be returned. He didn't say anything about the P0420 code issue just yet. I'm not sure how much he's gotten into it yet because end of week. Does anyone have an recommendations on an aftermarket clutch kit...
  5. V

    "Dead" cylinder with compression??

    Thank you guys SO much!!:flowers2::flowers2::flowers2: Sorry for the delay. Cable/Internet went out AGAIN, spotty yesterday and full out today ugh. Thank you Billwill, understood about CRD and CAT. And also cats. I love them too:) Sad to hear emissions laws are like that in SA. I've...
  6. V

    "Dead" cylinder with compression??

    Thank you SO MUCH BillWill!!:flowers2: Mine's an 03 actually! So far I printed out the Clutch section, Emissions Control, and Evaporative Emissions sections. I definitely understand what you and JasonJ are saying about the flywheel and its requirements. Makes perfect sense. I can live with...
  7. V

    "Dead" cylinder with compression??

    Update today. CEL. P0420. Catalytic converter says Google. Into shop tomorrow to check belt tensioner and discuss this code now too. My KJ either hates me or wants more of my attention. Ugh. Plan after engine R&R was JBA lift kit. Now all this other stuff has cropped up:( barongan...
  8. V

    "Dead" cylinder with compression??

    Hey sota! Hahah yeah. Any chance you want to help me remove a gear box and check a flywheel?:D I'm pretty near Branchburg actually! I'd love the name of the shop you trust, in case my current mechanic continues to be stumped. I won't publicly name the shop/mechanic who put himself on my...
  9. V

    "Dead" cylinder with compression??

    Looked it up. I'll only include the two relevant items from the full list. The first one may apply to the last shop. The second one to the new shop. According to NOLO: It is unlawful under the Auto Repairs Deceptive Practices Regulations and the New Jersey Consumer Fraud Act for an...
  10. V

    "Dead" cylinder with compression??

    Thanks BillWill! No worries!! I appreciate all angles of perspective. I hope you're wrong, only because it would be terrible if you're right:( Is checking the flywheel something I should do? Or ask the mechanic to do? I have to say at this point I believe - or want to believe - that he is being...
  11. V

    "Dead" cylinder with compression??

    Thanks for this JasonJ!! Super helpful. The Universe must be having fun with me at this point.. I texted the mechanic to say the sound was back. He was as surprised/confused/disappointed as me. I mentioned your belt tensioner theory. He said it's possible, he didn't even think about that...
  12. V

    "Dead" cylinder with compression??

    Thank you, BillWill!! :) Ughhh yes I know about not machining down the flywheel. I don't know if the mechanic knows about it tho. I didn't even think to review that with him. I will ask him tomorrow if it was machined down or not. Thank you for this! Edit to add: I like this new mechanic a...
  13. V

    "Dead" cylinder with compression??

    Thanks so much JasonJ!!:flowers2: The shifter/console issue is perplexing. New mechanic inspected it all again. Took it apart and checked the linkage, etc. He "promised" me all will be fine. He did that all on his own time at no charge. I'd just feel better knowing why/how it happened. It's...
  14. V

    "Dead" cylinder with compression??

    Thank you mtlmech, JasonJ, and J33Pfan for your replies. Sorry I ghosted on this thread. My internet went out July 26 thru Aug 5. July 30 I was bit by a Lyme disease carrier tick. Anyone who's had Lyme KNOWS what that is like. Wanted to update on my KJ since. I was waiting until all was good...
  15. V

    "Dead" cylinder with compression??

    Update New mechanic said: "Definitely sounds like a loud knocking noise coming from bottom end of the engine which means you would need an engine replacement." There was no loud knocking sound at time of breakdown. Just a lot of shaking. Last mech said, "it's running better (with...
  16. V

    "Dead" cylinder with compression??

    Thanks, guys. Very helpful. I appreciate this info so, so much. Deep breath. So, my take-away from this intel is, the first mechanic who diagnosed it either: 1) Doesn't know what he's talking about, misdiagnosed the issue and didn't assess beyond false speculation. (I might just be hoping...
  17. V

    "Dead" cylinder with compression??

    Yep. Speculation. No wonder the mechanic looked guilty, nervous, and all squirrely when I went in to pay and asked him to tell me again what he found. Funny you say it's the same as a retail parts store advice. That mechanic told me recently he wants to have his shop become like a regular "pep...
  18. V

    "Dead" cylinder with compression??

    Thank you SO much, JasonJ, ElCheapo, and tjkj2002!! This is super helpful, guys. Learning so much. I'm definitely deep into the rabbit hole now haha. It wasn't until last week that I learned what I was told by the shop was all based on speculation, nothing was actually looked at beyond...
  19. V

    "Dead" cylinder with compression??

    Thank you, ElCheapo. What if an injector (or spring) fails? Would either one cause fuel to fill the cylinder or related area and have compression from that? Or, if a rocker malfunctions, would it affect the injector's function at all? And/or would the injector still attempt to fill the...
  20. V

    "Dead" cylinder with compression??

    Guys, THANK YOU SO MUCH!! JasonJ: Agreed. Again, I'm not a mechanic but common sense = a leak as primary cause would affect all cylinders, not just one. I only mentioned it in relation to knowing the 2.5 qts low was very unusual, because I've been adding oil for past few years and know its...
Top